BetterThanDiamond.com AnswerBase

Sona Diamond Simulant - Information and Review (XPS analysis)

Sona Diamond Simulant has made a number of claims about their product, including statements that it is a non-CZ simulant created by high-pressure melding of natural diamond and sapphire, and that it has a special 'sapphire' coating. 
Their claims in Nov, 2007 included: 

"Sona Diamond, a Israel scientific gemological facility announced a revolutionary, patented process called formula A1203. A process of extreme heat and pressure applied to real diamond and sapphire to form a composite hybrid diamond simulant. The Sona Diamond will create a new category that blurs the line between natural diamond and simulant.

This scientific achievement is a milestone both for Sona Diamond and for the jewelry industry, as it represents the first known jewelry usage of a non-cubic zirconia form of diamond simulant."

As well as the following claims (11/2007):

*"If you have a plain old Cubic Zirconium, and you compare the Sona Diamond to it, you will see a huge difference in the cut, and the refraction index".
*"Sona Diamond has a special coating of a sapphire material"
*"Each Sona gemstone has a special Sapphire coating on the outside of the gemstone" 


To test this claim, in November of 2007, we hired Anderson Materials to independently purchase and test their non-CZ simulant via XPS analysis. 

The results: 

1. The gemstone is yttrium-stabilized cubic zirconia. [ In other words, its the plain old CZ that they claimed you could see a huge difference in when compared to a Sona Diamond]

2. No aluminum was found, therefore there is no sapphire infused into this surface. The carbon concentration was very low after the sputter removal of only 20 nm, so no significant diamond material could be infused into the gemstone surface.

3. This gemstone was oxygen-enriched, not slightly deficient the way many other cubic zirconia gemstones are.  This probably means that some carbon dioxide and water have reacted with the Zr in the near surface region, which commonly does occur with zirconia in time.

In otherwords, the independent testing shows the Sona Diamond Simulant to be ordinary cubic zirconinium.  (And thus, not the first non-CZ simulant, made from natural diamond and sapphire fused together). 

We note that the surface oxygen reaction spotted is theorized to be why plain CZ's go cloudy....the Asha diamond simulant's amorphous diamond coating prevents this reaction and is one benefit of our amorphous diamond process.

Sona is also not an "Israeli scientific gemological facility" as they represented...rather they are a jewelry store operating inside a mall.
See the following thread on our message boards:
More info on Sona Diamonds with photos 

The full XPS report is available here:
Sona Diamond Review




Would you like to...

Print this page Print this page

Email this page Email this page

Post a comment Post a comment

Subscribe me

Add to favorites Add to favorites

Remove Highlighting Remove Highlighting

Edit this Article

Quick Edit

Export to PDF

User Opinions (17 votes)

70% thumbs up 29% thumbs down

How would you rate this answer?



Thank you for rating this answer.

Related Articles

No related articles were found.

Attachments

No attachments were found.

Visitor Comments

No visitor comments posted. Post a comment

Post a comment

To post a comment for this article, simply complete the form below. Fields marked with an asterisk are required.
   Name:
   Email:
* Comment:
* Enter the code below:
 

Continue