Well it looks cushion shaped. Do you want squared? Ask him if the milgrain will make the corners slightly more squared once it's added. I like the cushion shape more, but just tell him you feel it is too rounded.
Plus, I zoomed in and I think the corners prongs on the Tiffany one with the milgrain around it kinda takes the curve out of it a bit and that is what you are seeing.
Edited by flashfrenzy (03/31/12 07:28 AM)