I'm sorry you guys dont like my e ring
I think what most people are seeing is the overdone setting. When you have a center stone that is 15+cts, most feel you don't need to dress it up too much more. I know it's subjective, but her particular setting is over the top, and to me, it cheapens the overall look.
Kat, yours is classic. It's simple and looks well done. I have a poor memory, but when I see it, I automatically think "that's a JBEG custom piece!" Is it?
Why am I worried about my 10mm round brilliant Wink CZ looking too big?
E, that is a far cry from almost 16cts. 10mm is big, but it's not outrageous. And if I recall, your setting is also on the simpler side. You'll be just fine.