Custom Search
Who's Online
1 registered (Jezebel), 26 Guests and 5 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Latest posts
Happy Birthday, borismom!
by Dana ♥
Today at 01:27 AM
Financing?
by DaynaM
Yesterday at 10:53 PM
Pre Honeymoon Slimdown
by LisaLou
Yesterday at 09:13 PM
Pictures of Ellie Lou
by Wink
Yesterday at 08:41 PM
Designing my cushion-cut light green moissanite e-ring!
by LisaLou
Yesterday at 07:13 PM
Forum Stats
9327 Members
52 Forums
45974 Topics
763394 Posts

Max Online: 279 @ 06/26/12 12:39 PM
Today's Birthdays
borismom, millerk, VW
Newest Members
himni, Ozisparkle, rtbrtb, olebightgal, B_Wong
9327 Registered Users
(Views)Popular Topics
First word that comes to your mind... 22419616
celebrity engagement rings! 3990007
Has anyone done HCG for weigh loss 2128330
Favorites perfumes? 1506230
Check this seller out... 1407719
Post your e-rings 1259889
The Amora Blog...the Amora Gem Chapter 1211959
Meet Mira(tm)...a sneak, brief intro 1146927
Anyone want to be weight loss buddies? 1059063
what's for supper tonight? 851400
Latest photos...
and a few hand shots ;)
Peach Gold and my OEC
Show your Vintage...
New milgrained bezels!
A full shot of my new earrings.
Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#733910 - 04/21/12 09:19 AM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
e.taylor Offline
The Black Orlov

Registered: 03/15/09
Posts: 4190
is it worth asking them to measure? 8.5mm will always be 8.5mm but 2 carats can vary widely in terms of how they face up (which you obviously know.) It may be worth finding out how that 2 carat faces up.

and if you know she wants big then I agree with the 8.5mm!

Top
#733923 - 04/21/12 09:49 AM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
RaiKai Offline
Afficionado

Registered: 02/04/10
Posts: 650
I wear an 8mm stone in a bezel solitaire on a 5.5ish finger. That is both my sweet spot and my max size for daily (wedding ring) wear. I tried on larger and I just did not like look on *me* or how it felt (height it was at, etc). In stones a .5mm does make a difference toe as it also means more depth as well as diameter.

Is she trying to pass it as diamond? Does she do any work with disadvantaged communities? Is she a flashier woman, or one who prefers her style to be a bit more understated? Is it going to be solitaire or a halo? A high setting or a low setting? A blinged out setting or a plainer one? Those to me also affect what size to go with.


Top
#733925 - 04/21/12 09:58 AM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: labelo]
sparkley mama Offline
Fiend

Registered: 04/24/10
Posts: 168
Originally Posted By: labelo
I'll be the voice on the other end and speak for going smaller smile

What size center do most of her friends/family have? I'm young (22) and from an average southern middle class family. The largest center stone any of my friends have is 1 ct (and most are .5 or .75ct), so I didn't want anything much larger than that. I decided to go with a 6mm (1.1ct) cushion with a halo, so it's a bit larger visually and has great finger coverage, but still looks somewhat believable and affordable (though I wouldn't want my boyfriend to spend the $6000+ the ring would cost if it were diamond!). For an anniversary down the road I'll probably get a 2-3ct asscher or krupps Amora Gem, but by that point we'll have stable, well-paying jobs, and it will seem a more realistic, responsible purchase.

All of that to say, beware of reverse shrinkage, lol. Unless you know that your girlfriend wants a big stone or come from a social circle that wears large stones, she's probably going to think a 2ct or 2.5ct stone is MASSIVE. Too big and she might feel a little uncomfortable wearing it.
Do you want the engagement to be a complete surprise? You might make it a fun outing together and take her to a jewelry store and try on various size stones. You can see what she likes size-wise and see what styles are her favorites. Then you can buy the actual ring yourself and have it be a surprise.


+1

Top
#733927 - 04/21/12 10:04 AM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
kangaroocrazy Offline
The Florentine Diamond

Registered: 02/25/11
Posts: 5296
Loc: Washington
I have a size 6 finger,..and my sweet spot for a solitaire is definitely 7.5.
So I would say go for the 8mm.

You can always halo her later...lol wink
_________________________
www.monroefunnyfarm.com

Top
#733952 - 04/21/12 11:38 AM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
labelo Offline
Mentor

Registered: 10/04/11
Posts: 803
Loc: US
Well if she liked the 2ct, then by all means go for it! smile

Are you planning on going with the Amora enhancement? I'd recommend it, as it will put your stone in a near-colorless range (H/I). Otherwise it might seem a bit yellow.

I'm assuming you're looking at rounds - if you do choose Amora (which most of the ladies on here would HIGHLY recommend), BTD and MoCo are currently sold out of 8.5mm, so that might factor into your decision! It just depends on when you'd want the ring.

I also want to throw out the option of getting an Amora OEC. I don't particularly like the round moissanite cut (it's not cut like your typical round brilliant diamond), but I LOVE the OECs. They're possible the most realistic/accurate moissanite cut I've seen, and they sparkle like mad, but with chunkier, antique-style flashes rather than the splintery ones common to well cut rounds. It's all about personal preference, though. Check out KatNewby's thread on her 9mm here:
http://betterthandiamond.com/discussion/ubbthreads.php/topics/733203/1

MoCo is getting a batch of Amora-ized OECs soon and they'll have 8mm and 8.5mm stones, but they'll probably sell out fairly quickly! They will be a bit more expensive than a regular round since they're a special cut.


Edited by labelo (04/21/12 11:45 AM)

Top
#733967 - 04/21/12 12:29 PM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: labelo]
thesmartguy Offline
Smitten

Registered: 08/16/11
Posts: 35
Here is a picture of the ring i purchased on her finger. The center stone is a 1.76 ct diamond. It faces up larger because of the depth. You can tell by the picture that the stone is not actually set in this picture, it is simply placed on the prongs to get an idea of how it would look with a round stone. I'm thinking an amora moissy would look great next to the diamonds on the engagement and wedding bands.

The picture is dark because it gives an idea of the setting. It also comes with a gorgeous matching band as well.



[/URL]


Edited by thesmartguy (04/21/12 12:32 PM)

Top
#733969 - 04/21/12 12:37 PM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: RaiKai]
LORRISSEY Offline
Omniscient

Registered: 04/19/12
Posts: 2500
Loc: CA
I agree with RaiKai. I am also a 5.5. I would love to have a GIANT stone, but every time I try them on. It just looks ridiculous on me. My fingers are very short so and my hands are tiny even for my size. I think size and wearability are key. I currently have a 1 ct princess cut diamond solitaire set VERY HIGH. I love the ring, but it's uncomfortable. I'm always banging it into things, replacing the small stones on the prongs.

I finally got an 8x6 moissy and had it set in a bezel very low and east west <-- to get more finger coverage and it's perfect. I get WAY more complements on this ring than my actual diamond ring.

But for me, I'm very active. I work with dogs and the low bezel is a lot more practical for me.

I'm thinking of getting my princess cut bezel set with a halo.

Top
#733987 - 04/21/12 02:14 PM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
Macy Offline
Connoisseur

Registered: 01/27/09
Posts: 1533
These pics aren't exactly what you're looking for, but you might like to see in general what these ct weights looks like on sizes the same as or close to your girlfriend's finger size. Personally I love the look of big rocks on small fingers. These are just some of the few that I've bookmarked:
2.5 ct Asha on size 3.75 finger: http://betterthandiamond.com/discussion/...7207#Post537207
2.45 ct on size 5 finger: http://www.pricescope.com/forum/show-me-...60.html#2408250
2 ct on size 5 finger: http://www.pricescope.com/forum/show-me-...es-t154886.html
A diff 2 ct on size 5: http://www.pricescope.com/forum/show-me-...ro-t150452.html
2.5 ct on size 4: http://www.pricescope.com/forum/show-me-...ng-t133931.html
2.398 ct on size 4.5: http://www.pricescope.com/forum/show-me-...ce-t137298.html
HTH

Top
#733988 - 04/21/12 02:20 PM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: Macy]
e.taylor Offline
The Black Orlov

Registered: 03/15/09
Posts: 4190
Macy, you are made of awesome.

Top
#733990 - 04/21/12 02:28 PM Re: 2ct (8mm) vs 2.5 (8.5mm) moissy size difference pics or vid? [Re: thesmartguy]
KatNewby Offline
Connoisseur

Registered: 02/07/11
Posts: 1445
Loc: Michigan
Originally Posted By: thesmartguy
Kat is your Amora in that size still really white as the smaller ones are? Or do you see teh infamous "warmth"? I've only seen Amora in 7mm.


Hi SmartGuy smile

I have an OEC (Old European Cut) Amora, and it does have some warmth. It is a J color, so while it still falls in the 'near colorless' range, it is still a little tinted.
I have no qualms about the color though, because the cut steals the show, and since it is meant to mimic and antique stone, a little warmth is pretty fitting! Also, be aware that the OEC cut faces up less white than the Round Brillant (RB) Amoras.

A large RB will be more white than a J, and will likely grade an H but face up as a G.

So while I can't recommend the cut of the OEC over the RB enough, if color is the ultimate factor to you and not faceting, then I would point you in the direction of the RB Amora.

(Labelo posted my thread already, so you can see if that amount of tint would not suit your liking, as that is totally okay too! )
_________________________
Dream in Pastel!

Top
Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >



Moderator:  Dana ♥, gemcat, tricksi