You say that now, but you know you'll watch. It's like a train wreck, you just can't turn away!

Nope, I won't, few years back when was down to that gray hair guy i got sick of it and did not watch the rest

I'm been trying to quit Idol for years! I've actually enjoyed these last 2 season w/o Simon.

I didn't think I'd watch it w/o Simon, but I actually like it better!

This is my first season back since Ellen was on. I couldnt stand it.

I am tiring of the fluff, and lack of true constructive critisism. I wish they would be honest with them, they dont have to be brutal like Simon was, just honest.

I am clueless as to who will win now. I thought Skylar had a great chance at winning. Who do you all think will win it?

It's a tough one considering it is obvious that it is a popularity thing, unfortunately

I really think now Joshua should win..so I will say him

If PP wins he will soon enough disappear into obscurity like Kris, David, and Lee. Turn the lights down low boy is successful because of his genre of music. Jessica (if she wins) would be about as successful as Jordin, lol. She has years to grow up before she has the potential to be anywhere where J Hudson is. Hollie has the potential to be a pop version of Carrie. Remember, her personality and performance level was awful when she was on Idol. Her performance has improved so much, but I don't know a about personality, lol, and well she still is super-mega successful! I just think Hollie *could* have the same sucess if she wins. Joshua is the freshest. Young but beyond his years in performance. I think he has the most potential to eventually become one of his generations "greats". I don't really like him much, I odn't how popular he is. I dunno. You can't deny his talent, and I think overall he is beyond the others.

I agree 100%, plus I think there is one Idol and was Kelly Clarkson...love her. She was in the dark for a while after firing her producer or something like that, but she came back string again. Every song is a hit.

OMGosh - she is the best - we picked her from the first show...after her audition - hubby and I felt she would win...and she did. Her voice gives me chills...the good kind. I don't really get any chills at all from any of the current "best last 5 ever" (they keep saying that?) no chills... but I adore Phil!

After tonight I think its gonna be Josh and Phil in the finale! ETA: Jessica is 16, why does she insist of singing these old songs? It drives me nuts!