The first ring Nick is really a guy pleaser I think. My guy was looking at that exact same ring last night but had the same concerns about it being to "fashion-ish" and not enough "I'm a committed man-ish" The middle ring is o.k but the last one you linked is really rather nice. Classy and modern with that wholesome traditional feel at the same time. It really comes together nicely with that unique finish to it.
Dana 4 Prez!