Well, 2 thoughts... Yes, you should know what you think first, before you listen to what others think. And 2, you really need to see things in person. Pictures are all blown up and realy change the look of things. I would tell him you are unsure, but that you need to see it in real life to be sure, so to ship it. But that you may need to send it back for tweaking.
Joseph Schubach Jewelers