I love the gallery of the Sophie but the flow of the LM one a little better, so I voted Sophie but think the two should be mashed together!

I voted for the second one!

I don't know what the pricing v. your budget is, but if you can afford the Leon, I think it's the best. It's sort-of flawless. If your DH doesn't like the MC2, I think it would be a bad idea - the ring would always have bad juju.

I like the Sophie basket better. I don't like the sort of unattached look to the Leon.

I do not like the way the LM looks face on. I think the curve down from the basket in the shank makes it look too narrow compared to the size of the diamond. I like the profile of it though.

Mc2 all the way!! It's sooo different and interesting. I love all the designs on that site. I think I'm sort of 'over' pave. The Mc2 definitely stands out in a crowd.

What a hard hard choice!
But if it was for me,..I keep going back to Jbegs!

LM by far! Flows much better. I love MC2 rings but not this one, it's got nothing on the LM IMO

Will JBeg still make any of their rings? If so, I would go with that one and ask them to adjust same details that you favor in the other rings.

From what I have read on here, I think Erica is quite meticulous and pours her heart into her projects. I think you will get perfection from her. I've read LM can be temperamental to work with. I don't know if that is true but it is what I've read on PS. But I like the split shank slightly better on the LM.