I think I like them both equally, but they are two completely different types of rings to me. The first one looks like a traditional three stone ring with a peachy pink center. The second one looks like a classic peachy pink center stone ring with baguette accents, if that makes any sense to you. It would depend on which look I was desiring. The peachy pink moissanite is definitely more "front and center" in the second ring. If I was desiring a three stone ring look, I would choose the first one.