Does anyone have any experience with both of these cuts?

I am replacing my 1ct cushion cut due to the setting needing to be remade by DK. I decided that this would be the time to upgrade my stone, since we are starting from scratch, but there are no cushion cuts around. I fell in love and ordered both a 2ct Asha Flanders AND also a 1.75 Vintage Cushion Cut. I just can't decide!!

Does anyone have any input from experience on these? I am going to see them both in 2 days when they are delivered, but I would also love any advice. I will post pics of the stones if any of you gals would like me to.

Confusion!! I also really love the Elongated Cushion Cut but was advised that some of the fancier cuts don'tlook as realistic, and this is my engagement ring that I wear every day.
What to do? What to do!